No, the title is not a reference to the viral story that floats around the internet—the one that claims a peer-reviewed study in the U.S. National Library of Medicine found that casein content in cheese is actually as addictive as a hard drug—but to my recent summer adventure to visit my sister in Coos Bay, Oregon (about 90 miles south of Newport, for you Rogue Ales fans). Making good use of my limited time, I decided to hit some bike trails, breweries, university tours (for the edification of my high school daughter), and of course, any cheesemakers I could find along the path. 

Photos by John Rockwell - Through this window is where the magic happens, though on the Monday when I visited, there was no cheese being made.

Loleta Cheese Factory—Loleta, CA. Just a few miles south of Eureka, this sleepy little seaside town is home to Loleta Cheese Factory, a small operation in a historical landmark wood-paneled building. Bob Laffranchi, who owns the business with his wife Carol, was once a high school teacher teaching dairy farming, so this place resonated with me in a special way. Laffranchi turned his classroom lessons on cheesemaking into reality in 1982 when he formed his company. The focus of Loleta Cheese is mainly plain and flavored Jack, Cheddar, Havarti and Fontina—no bloomy rinds here, and no evidence of natural-rind aged cheeses or sheep and goat milk-based cheeses. Some cheeses are sent away to be cold-smoked and then are returned to the shop to be sold. High quality annatto-colored cheddars and jacks each hold their own and are what you’d expect of mass-produced style cheeses done on a much smaller scale—better quality, with some nuance. The Orange Peel Cheddar I bought was strangely addictive and popular with my family. At first, the flavor is difficult to categorize, but it definitely grows on you. If you want Loleta Cheese, you can visit the shop (which also sells jellies, jams and nuts), or you can have their cheese shipped to you during non-summer months.

Cypress Grove Chèvre in Arcata has kept the old-world feel by keeping the original barn buildings that were part of this homestead property. The company restored the mural on the rear building when they bought the property.

Cypress Grove Chèvre—Arcata, CA. For me, this was one of a couple of “holy grail” stops on my tourist tour. This creamery is home to the famous and award-winning Humboldt Fog, Bermuda Triangle, Truffle Tremor and various soft and flavored goat’s milk soft-spread cheeses. If you haven’t tried Humboldt Fog—an ash-ripened goat’s milk Brie—then go out and buy a chunk right now. There’s really nothing quite like it, and it is difficult for me to describe or put into any particular category. It is sublime, and I’m not the only one who thinks so. In the California State Fair this year, Cypress Grove took thirteen medals—eight golds and two best-in-category, which included first-place wins for Humboldt Fog (mini) and Truffle Tremor.

Owned by Swiss dairy giant Emmi, Cypress Grove’s production facilities are immense and impressive. Of course that blue Cypress Grove badge always means great cheese.

Even though they don’t offer a full tour of their facility, I just had to walk onto the property to see it for myself. Visitors to the factory are shown into the employee breakroom, which opens up to the final-stage affinage for Humboldt Fog and Truffle Tremor (a truffle-flavored goat’s milk Brie). One cool thing about the breakroom is that they keep a platter of very expensive cheese out for tasting and sampling for employees. At the end of my short walk to the breakroom and back, I was handed a couple of soft flavored chèvres as a souvenir!

In Southern California, Cypress Grove cheese can be found at finer cheese retail outlets—I have seen it at Sprouts, Ralph’s, Gelsons, and Whole Foods.

These creameries were only a glimpse into the wonderland of craft cheese. Coastal Oregon and Marin County proved to me that there is a renaissance in cheese, and they will be the subject of my next installment.

A humidity-controlled room full of Humboldt Fog is a wondrous thing to behold. There are mini rounds in front and larger rounds to the back. Proper affinage is important for the superior and delicate rind development of their signature cheese.

Loleta Cheese Factory
252 Loleta Dr
Loleta, CA 95551
(707)733-5470

Cypress Grove Chèvre
1330 Q St, Arcata, CA 95521
(707)825-1100